Why Is It So Hard for Moms to Say Yes to Themselves?

A few months ago, I was talking with a Mom about an upcoming Chief of Mom Life event. She genuinely wanted to be there. Then she told me she couldn’t come because she had to take her child to practice.

I asked whether her husband could cover practice.

She paused. She said she would have to ask.

As it turned out, he wasn’t able to. But what stayed with me was the pause. The question was new to her. And there were probably ten other kids on that team, which meant ten other families heading to the same field at the same time. I don’t know whether a ride with one of them would have worked. Neither did she. The option never entered the conversation.

She was not being careless with her own time. She was being responsible. She saw practice as hers to cover, and she held herself accountable for it, the way so many of us hold ourselves accountable for nearly everything. The cost of that accountability was an evening she genuinely wanted.

I recognized it immediately, because I do the same thing.

The Thirty-Minute Drive

At the first soccer practice of this season, I drove my daughter to the field. The thought had already crossed my mind to ask my husband to take her by bike, a ten-minute round trip for him. But I told myself it would be easier to run her over in the car. Fifteen minutes, I figured.

It took thirty.

Only after the drive ran twice as long as I expected did I give myself permission to ask him to take her by bike the rest of the season. He was glad to. He was simply following my lead, and until then, my lead had been to not ask.

Fifteen minutes of my time felt acceptable to spend. Ten minutes of his felt like something that required justification. Now, in the moment, I ask: If my time cost the same as everyone else’s, what would I do? That day, the math was simple. The problem was that I had quietly priced my own time at nearly zero.

But my husband was not my only option. Several families were already driving straight from school to practice, and my daughter could have ridden with any of them, at no inconvenience to anyone. Instead, I picked her up so she could change at home first, trading forty-five minutes of my time for her preference.

I see this from the other side, too. When I offer to drive another child somewhere I am already going, the other Mom almost always asks, “Are you sure?” She hesitates to let me spend five minutes that would save her an hour. From where I sit, the math is obvious. From where she sits, it never is.

I know I am fortunate to have a husband who says yes so readily. Not every Mom has that. But neighbors, classmates, and other parents are often closer than we think. We rarely look for them because we have already decided our time is the cheapest option.

That is the belief underneath so many of our choices:

I am willing to make significant sacrifices for my family. I am not willing to cost my family, or anyone else, something for me, even something small.

Written out, it is completely illogical. It runs deep anyway.

What Makes It So Hard

In our original research, the Mom Life Leadership Survey, 49% of Moms said they struggle to stay connected to themselves.

When I read that number, I did not see Moms who lack discipline or who don’t care about their own wellbeing. I saw Moms living by the same quiet accounting I live by. Staying connected to yourself requires time spent on yourself. And time spent on yourself is exactly what this belief tells us is too expensive, especially when it might cost someone else even a little. The belief even shrinks what we count as taking care of ourselves. We call a bath self-care. A bath is hygiene.

Part of what makes this belief so hard to see is that it rarely announces itself. No single choice feels like a sacrifice. A fifteen-minute pickup. A quick run to the store for glue. Staying up to finish one more thing. Each one is small, and each one makes sense on its own.

But they add up, and our wellbeing pays for it. Hobbies we loved get forgotten. Workouts get skipped. Sleep gets sacrificed. The cost to someone else is visible and specific, so it is easy to protect. The benefit to us is harder to measure, so it almost always loses. The cost is real, even if it is immeasurable.

Seeing the pattern clearly matters, because a pattern can be understood. And what can be understood can be designed around. That is part of what it means to lead our lives and families intentionally: recognizing the assumptions shaping our choices and deciding whether they still serve us.

Seeing It Differently

I haven’t unlearned this belief. I try to be more intentional, but I still catch myself reaching for the option that costs me and spares everyone else.

What helps me most is not fighting the belief but reframing it. Two questions do that for me. The same instinct that puts my family first becomes a reason to put myself on the list.

What Would You Want for Your Kids?

I step back and ask a bigger question. I picture my daughters grown, with children of their own. Would I want them to give up the hobbies they love, their health, their friendships, and their own wellbeing to care for their kids?

No. Not for a moment.

This is not about performing self-care so my children will see it. Role modeling done only for the audience does not hold. But it is a useful test. If I would never want this for my daughters, I should not accept it for myself.

How Does Your Yes Help Them?

We all know the advice to put on our own oxygen mask first. Most of us take just enough air to survive so everyone else can thrive. We assume that putting ourselves first takes something away from our kids. Often, it gives them something.

When I am on the treadmill, that time is mine. If my kids have a disagreement, they work it out without me. That is not neglect. It is practice. Every time they solve a problem on their own, they become a little more independent, a little more resilient, and a little more flexible.

When I step in, I take those chances away from them. When I protect my own time, I give those chances back.

Why Systems Work

Because no single choice seems worth defending, deciding in the moment rarely works. Systems make the decision once, so I don’t have to make it again and again.

When I was working full-time, I handed every dental appointment to my husband. Scheduling them, driving to them, sitting in the waiting room. All of it. There was nothing to weigh each time, no moment where I had to decide whether my time was worth protecting. The system had already decided. He was not helping me manage the appointments. He owned them, which meant I no longer had to carry the responsibility.

Building structure around my own yeses has been harder. Making time for myself is easy when it costs no one, like stepping away from work to meditate or exercise. The hard part is when my yes requires someone in my family to give something up.

It was unsurprisingly hard for me to think of an example. The one that comes to mind is from when our kids were young. My husband and I took turns putting them to bed. I had a system, which my husband supported: if the kids weren’t asleep by 9 p.m. on my night, I would “tap out,” and he would take over so I could go to sleep.

It worked because the decision was already made. At 9 p.m., I did not have to weigh my sleep against his evening or wonder whether I was asking too much. We had agreed in advance, so the agreement did the asking for me.

I am still learning to build more systems like this. But that one showed me what works: when the yes is decided before the moment arrives, the belief has far less room to argue.

Your Next Yes

I think often about the Mom who paused when I asked about her husband. What stays with me is that the question had never come up. So many of our yeses to ourselves disappear before we ever consider them.

So here is an invitation. Choose one thing that keeps you connected to yourself: movement, learning, quiet time to think, a hobby that is yours, or an evening with other Moms. Then ask yourself:

What structure would make this a yes before the week even begins?

Who could own something, permanently, so this is not a decision I have to make again?

How might my yes help my family, too?

If you would like a place to start, Chief of Mom Life workshops and our weekly Lead Your Life cohorts are designed for exactly this kind of work: seeing the beliefs that shape how you lead, and building the systems that let what matters, including you, move forward.

It will not always feel natural. It does not need to. You have always been willing to do things for your family. Saying yes to yourself is one of the best things you can do for them.

This post is part of an ongoing exploration of the idea that motherhood is leadership. To read the essay that started this work, see Motherhood Is Leadership.

Read the essay →
Next
Next

Leadership in Practice: Letting Go Without Stepping Back